Let’s get into our curated list of the top NYC fitness influencers on Instagram. Psst! Here’s a secret tip: don’t forget to grab the free influencer marketing tools (like email templates, a contract, a brief, and more) at the bottom of this influencer list.
🤫 Here’s the ultimate list of the best health and fitness creators in New York City. 👇.
Jules Carmaux8 min readLast updated: May 26, 2026How this list was built
ClickAnalytic tracks 400M+ creator profiles. This page gives you a useful public shortlist; inside the platform you can search the full database, compare audience quality and unlock verified contacts.
The ranking
The top 25 American creators, ranked by reach and vetted for engagement, audience quality and commercial fit.
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
You're seeing 25
Filter the full creator database by engagement, audience location and audience quality, then export verified contacts.
Search the creator databaseExplore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
You're seeing 25
Filter the full creator database by engagement, audience location and audience quality, then export verified contacts.
Search the creator databaseExplore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Explore the audience split between influencers, businesses, mass followers, and real potential buyers. See full breakdown
Creator sizes
Bigger is not always better. The right size depends on whether you mainly want awareness or action. Smaller creators bring a tighter audience and stronger engagement; larger ones bring reach and recognition.
Emerging creators · 1K-10K
Highest trust and engagement. Best for hyper-local or niche campaigns where authenticity matters most.
High-efficiency creators · 10K-50K
Best balance of reach, engagement and cost. Ideal for product launches, DTC brands and performance campaigns.
Scale creators · 50K-500K
Broad visibility and recognition. Good for awareness and brand positioning at scale.
Celebrity-level creators · 500K+
Mass awareness and cultural reach. Premium pricing; use where broad visibility matters most.
Not sure which size fits your campaign? Match creators to your exact goal and budget.
Find your creatorsWas this list of US influencers handy?
Why not look at some of these other influencers in USA:
What metrics did we use to find the trendiest NYC Fitness Influencers?
We asked our influencer marketing platform to find influencers with these metrics:
👉 Followers: Between 5K and 5M
These US influencers fit snugly in that micro-influencer space where they can wow crowds and convert them into sales.
👉 Engagement rate: Above 2%
Nobody wants to work with a dull influencer or one with fake followers. Who’s got time to use a fake follower checker?
We used our platform to analyse the audience and ensure they engaged with the content. The higher the engagement, the better.
👉 Activity level: Active
We also used our platform to find active NYC influencers. There are no duds here.
👉 Growth: On the up!
All these influencers have had an audience growth of 20% or more over the last couple of months.
What does it mean?
These creators are trending, and their audiences are growing!
You identified the best influencer for your brand.
Next, grab some of these freebies:
👉 Learn how to find someone’s Instagram email.
👉 Use these 5 free influencer marketing email templates to simplify your outreach.
👉 Download this free influencer marketing brief.
👉 And this free influencer marketing contract.
👉 Then, learn to recognise the 7 essential influencer marketing metrics to monitor.
You are officially on your way to making money with influencers. 🤑
For developers & data teams
The same live data we used to rank American creators, followers, engagement, audience quality and more across 400M+ creators, is available programmatically through the ClickAnalytic Influencer Marketing API.
Jump straight to the same niche in another market, or another niche in the same one.
🇨🇦Top 18 Canadian Fitness InfluencersCanada · Fitness🇬🇧Top 25 UK Fitness Influencers on InstagramUnited Kingdom · Fitness🇮🇹Top 25 Italian fitness influencersItaly · Fitness
🇫🇷Top 50 French Fitness Influencers on InstagramFrance · Fitness
🌍Top 10 TikTok fitness influencersWorldwide · Fitness
🇧🇷Top Fitness Instagram Influencers in BrazilBrazil · Fitness
🇺🇸Top 25 US Travel Influencers on InstagramUnited States · Travel
🇺🇸Top 25 US Beauty InfluencersUnited States · Beauty
🇺🇸Top 25 US Fashion Influencers on InstagramUnited States · Fashion
🇺🇸Top 25 US Food Influencers on InstagramUnited States · Food🇺🇸Top 25 US Fitness Influencers on InstagramUnited States · Fitness
🇺🇸Top 25 US Tech InfluencersUnited States · Tech
Written by
Co-Founder and Content Lead at Click Analytic, covering influencer marketing, audience analytics, and creator economy trends.
Build your own vetted shortlist in minutes. Search 400M+ creators, filter by audience, and export verified contacts. Free for 14 days.
Start your search free
